Ice cream is something everyone has an opinion on, in large part because there’s so many options! Soft serve or hard serve? Cone or cup? And that doesn’t even touch on all the flavors. Of course there’s traditional favorites like mint chocolate chip or good old-fashioned vanilla. The more adventurous aficionados go for more exotic flavorings like rosewater pistachio or Labreh apricot cardamom. Food & Wine magazine recently took on the monumental task of ranking the best ice cream shops in every state. Fortunes Ice Cream in the little town of Tivoli won out for the coveted title of best ice cream in New York.

How adorable is this colorful little shop? It hasn't been open long, but it's already found great success in the burgeoning downtown community of Tivoli.
Lauren Adler/Google Maps
They've got a variety of flavors, both the typical run of the mill ones and also the more exotic.
Andrew D./Google Maps
Please note that their flavors do change throughout the season.
With plenty of dairy-free options, vegans don't need to be left out!
Fortunes Ice Cream/Facebook
This one's their brûlée grapefruit sorbet, a delicious dairy-free treat. It's grapefruit sorbet blended with burnt honey candied grapefruit peels. Yum!

Related Stories

Savor The Most Adorable Mini Treats In New York At Buffalo Cake Pops

Savor The Most Adorable Mini Treats In New York At Buffalo Cake Pops

 Devour Incredible Homemade Cookie Creations At Cathy's Cookie Kitchen In New York

Devour Incredible Homemade Cookie Creations At Cathy's Cookie Kitchen In New York

 Barkeater Chocolates In New York Will Have Your Stomach Growling And Mouth Watering

Barkeater Chocolates In New York Will Have Your Stomach Growling And Mouth Watering
Traditional dairy lovers rejoice; of course they have milk-filled options as well.
Fortunes Ice Cream/Facebook
This is sweet pea with mint. Definitely an unusual flavor you won't find just anywhere!
Whether you get cones or cups or buy it by the pint, you won't be disappointed with whatever you choose.
Fortunes Ice Cream/Google Maps
They have a cute little outside seating area. The colorful furniture really adds to the fun vibe.
Ali J/Google Maps

Do you feel like the list got it wrong? Share your favorite New York ice cream shop in the comments!

For more information about Fortunes Ice Cream, visit their website or Facebook.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New York

Featured Addresses
Fortunes Ice Cream, 55 Broadway, Tivoli, NY 12583, USA