One thing in this life is for sure: sometimes, people do evil things that simply cannot be explained or understood. Some people do absolutely terrible things and later show remorse – but often, they don’t show any emotions at all. Indiana is not immune to the phenomenon – the Hoosier State has been home to its fair share of human monsters, and here are our picks for some of the downright creepiest Indiana serial killers on the books.

Related Stories

The Hidden Nature Park In Indiana With Its Very Own Springs, Two Caves, And So Much More

The Hidden Nature Park In Indiana With Its Very Own Springs, Two Caves, And So Much More

In 2020, Indiana's Governor Holcomb Declared That 1 Million Trees Would Be Planted In 5 Years. We Did It Early.

In 2020, Indiana's Governor Holcomb Declared That 1 Million Trees Would Be Planted In 5 Years. We Did It Early.

Trade Boots For Paddles On The Legendary 9 Lakes Challenge At Indiana's Chain O'Lakes State Park

Trade Boots For Paddles On The Legendary 9 Lakes Challenge At Indiana's Chain O'Lakes State Park

If you’re interested in more details about Herbert Baumeister, check out this previous article in which we dive a little deeper into his story.

So, what do you think? Are there any Indiana serial killers that we missed? Tell us some of the scariest stories about them you know in the comments.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.