If you’re into frozen yogurt, you may have heard of CUPS. The small, local chain has four New Jersey locations, and one location in Yonkers. HOWEVER, only one froyo location is also an amazing ice cream destination. While you can find fantastic ice cream sandwiches all over the Garden State (Milk Sugar Love in Jersey City, Lexylicious in Point Pleasant Beach, and Peace Pie in Cape May/Ocean City/Ventnor City, for example), you can head to CUPS in Fair Lawn to build the ice cream sandwich of your dreams.

If you haven't heard of CUPS, it's a self-serve froyo spot with loads of toppings. Their froyo is low in fat or fat free, has no high fructose corn syrup, and is packed with Vitamins A and C.
Image/Google Maps
But enough about froyo...because CUPS in Fair Lawn has homemade ice cream! Flavors rotate and include: chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, chocolate raspberry truffle, brownie batter fudge, mint chocolate chip, cannoli cream, nutella, raspberry cheesecake, and s'mores (among others).
Google/Cynthia Chan

Related Stories

The Milkshakes From This Marvelous New Jersey Sweet Shop Are Almost Too Wonderful To Be Real

The Milkshakes From This Marvelous New Jersey Sweet Shop Are Almost Too Wonderful To Be Real

 This DIY Donut Event In New Jersey Keeps Selling Out And It's Not Hard To See Why

This DIY Donut Event In New Jersey Keeps Selling Out And It's Not Hard To See Why

 This Eclectic Soda Pop & Candy Shop In New Jersey Can't Be Missed

This Eclectic Soda Pop & Candy Shop In New Jersey Can't Be Missed
Then, there are the toppings. You'll find: Chocolate Chips, Cookie & Cream Pieces, Graham Cracker Pieces, Fruity Pebbles, Chopped Almonds, Hot Fudge, Sprinkles, Whipped Cream,and many more…
Google/John DeWitt
And then, there are the fresh baked cookies. Flavors include: Chocolate Chip, Gluten Free Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Oatmeal Raisin, M&M, Macadamia White Chocolate Chip, Sugar, and Chocolate Chocolate Chip. Yum!
Google/Cynthia Chan
Mix and match cookies, toppings, and ice cream flavors to create something spectacularly delicious, like this! What other sweet treats can you conjure up?
Image/Cups

First things first…what’s your dream ice cream sandwich? Mine is brownie batter fudge ice cream, sandwiched in between chocolate chip cookies, and topped with cookies ‘n cream pieces. You can find CUPS at 2170 Promenade Boulevard in Fair Lawn. Where can I find your favorite ice cream sandwich in New Jersey? Let me know in the comments!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New Jersey